The Origins of Classic Halloween Symbols (Spooky Month #8) (#89)
LISTEN TO THIS EPISODE
Listen to or download this episode right here on this page, or find more places to listen below.
More Places to Listen
(Listening on Apple Podcasts or Spotify? Please leave us a quick star rating and/or review - it'd mean a lot!)
About the Episode
In my last spooky episode, I talked about haunted houses and I said that it was quite a classic Halloween topic to cover. So I thought I’d go with classic Halloween this time too!
A lot of things can make you think instantly of Halloween. Ghosts, bats, pumpkins, and black cats show up in seasonal décor everywhere. But where did these symbols come from?
Related Episode: The History of Halloween (#37)
Links & Resources
- Halloween Symbols – The Origins of 8 Classic Halloween Icons
- 15 Spooky Halloween Traditions and Their Origins
- Halloween Symbols and What They Mean
- 15 Halloween Symbols Explained
- How Did Black Cats Become Halloween Symbols?
- Why is a Black Cat bad luck?
- Priapus | Facts, Information, and Mythology
- Scarecrows and God Priapus
- Scarecrow History and Folklore
- The Scarecrow Story: How the symbol of Autumn came to be
- Ghosts – Halloween for All
- Halloween Symbols – Ghosts and Spirits
- Halloween Symbols – Release the Bats
- Halloween Symbols – Orange and Black
Full Episode Notes
If you can’t listen to the episode for accessibility reasons, or you just want to refer to the notes as you listen, you can find the full in-depth notes for this episode below.
The Origins of Classic Halloween Symbols (#89)
In my last spooky episode, I talked about haunted houses and I said that it was quite a classic Halloween topic to cover. So I thought I’d go with classic Halloween this time too!
A lot of things can make you think instantly of Halloween. Ghosts, bats, pumpkins, and black cats show up in seasonal decor everywhere. But where did these symbols come from? That’s what I’m going to talk about today!
I’m not going to go too much into the history of Halloween itself because we actually have a whole episode on that! Episode 37 - The History of Halloween - was actually the very first Spooky Month episode we did last year, so go and listen to that if you want to know where the spooky holiday came from. But for this episode, let’s dive into some spooky symbols and where they came from.
Jack O’ Lanterns
Let’s start with arguably the most famous spooky season symbol: the Jack O’ Lantern. The pumpkin lantern has become one of the most well-known Halloween symbols, as families every year get together to pick out their pumpkins and carve faces in them. But few people know the supposed Irish folklore where the carved pumpkin originates. (Ellie, I think you actually covered this briefly in your History of Halloween episode.)
Jack O’ Lanterns, which were originally turnips instead of pumpkins, are supposedly based on an Irish legend about a man named Stingy Jack who repeatedly trapped the Devil and only let him go on the condition that Jack would never go to Hell. When Jack died, however, Heaven refused him and Hell couldn’t take him either because of the deal that he would never go to Hell. So Jack was condemned to wander the Earth as a ghost for all eternity. The Devil sent Jack back home with — depending on how the story is told — a lump of burning coal, or an ever-burning ember of hellfire to light his way. Needing something to carry this hot coal, Jack found a turnip and carved out a lantern for himself.
Eventually, locals began carving frightening faces into their own gourds to scare off evil spirits. They realised pumpkins would make a better candle holder than the traditional turnip, and henceforth, the Jack O’Lantern was born.
Black Cats
Next up is black cats. Bear with me on this one — I’ve got a whole feline history lesson here. (I’m talking over two pages of notes.) Prior to the 4th century, cats were adored around the world. The ancient Egyptians worshipped them, devoting entire cities to feline deities that protected their people from loathsome creatures like snakes and scorpions.
Some cats were so honored that they received the same mummification after death as humans did. In 1888, an Egyptian farmer uncovered a large tomb filled with 80,000 cat mummies, dating to 2000 BC. In Ancient Egypt, killing a cat was considered a capital crime. And as the Egyptian empire fell to the reign of Christianity, the domestic cat spread rapidly into Europe.
Cats were still heavily associated with goddesses when Roman Emperor Theodosius banned all pagan worship in 391 CE. (With this he also banned the Olympics, so here’s a plug for you to listen to my episode about that. It’s episode 78.) For the next few centuries, cats, while no longer allowed to be worshipped, were generally left unscathed.
Then we come to the Celtic festival, Samhain (Sah-win). (You may have seen this word before - it’s spelled SAMHAIN. Now you know how to pronounce it. It’s not Sam-hain.) Samhain takes place between sunset on October 31 and sunset on November 1 to mark the end of harvest season. This is when we have maybe the most direct connotation of black cats being a Halloween symbol.
On Samhain, it was believed that the Cat Sìth—a Celtic fairy creature that was said to resemble a large black cat with a white spot on its chest—would bless any house that left a saucer of milk out for it to drink. Likewise, the Cat Sìth cursed those houses that did not leave out a saucer of milk. In Scotland, Cat Sith was believed to have the ability to steal a dead person’s soul before the gods could claim it, so people would sit night and day with a dead body prior to its burial to protect it from the Sith. Folklore like this, and the association of cats with Samhain (Sah-win), likely also carried over into Halloween.
Things unfortunately start going downhill from here for cats when we get to the Middle Ages. It’s not clear whether black cats in particular were already a bad luck omen before the 13th century, but they definitely would be after Pope Gregory IX (4th) published Vox in Rama on 13th June 1233. Vox in Rama was a decree condemning a German heresy known as Luciferian, a form of devil worship. One of the “devils” this satanic cult was said to worship took the form of a black cat. This was the beginning of the persecution of felines in continental Europe, resulting in the deaths of millions of cats over the next 300 years.
The Church’s official condemnation of black cats led to their association with another prevalent Halloween symbol: the witch. In 1484, Pope Innocent VIII (8th) declared that the cat was the “devil’s favorite animal and idol of all witches.”
The fact that cats were independent, indifferent, and often nocturnal meant that people believed they were witches’ familiars, or supernatural entities that assisted or acted as a vessel for the witch. Numerous recorded witch trials from the 16th and 17th centuries provide witness statements about cats (often black ones) doing the bidding of and “consorting with” the woman who was accused of witchcraft. Because of this, cats often were burned along with their human companions.
In the 1500s, there arose the belief that witches could shape-shift themselves into the form of black cats so they could roam freely about the country, wreaking havoc and spying on people. There is an English folktale in which a father and son, traveling home late one night, saw a black cat cross their path. The son threw a stone at the cat, fearing it was a witch’s familiar, and the stone hit the cat in the left leg. The injured animal gave forth an unholy shriek and fled under the stoop of a house belonging to a woman long suspected of being a witch. The next morning, the father and son met the old woman at the local marketplace and saw that she was limping on the same leg. From that day, the people in that town were sure that the woman was an evil witch that prowled their town at night in the shape of a black cat, looking to do mischief against anyone who crossed her.
We go next to Colonial America, when the settlers started arriving on the shores of New England. The belief that witches could turn themselves into black cats crossed the Atlantic with the first American settlers, and was a firmly-held superstition in New England by the time of the Salem witch hunts. The belief was so strong that Puritans began the practice of burning black cats on Shrove Tuesday to protect their homes from fire.
Black cat stories also haunted the Southern United States. Many Southern folktales feature supernatural black cats who are thought to be witches or demons in disguise. Pirates also believed that a black cat moving toward them meant bad luck, and if a black cat walked onto a pirate ship and then walked off again, the ship would sink on its next voyage.
Finally, in the last couple of centuries, things finally started looking up again for cats. By the 19th century, society no longer regarded cats as deceitful creatures. They became symbols of mystery in literature and poetry — for example, in 1843, Edgar Allen Poe published his short story “The Black Cat” to immediate acclaim.
The 20th century saw cats as cherished pets, though black cats were still portrayed darkly in the arts. Beginning in the 1930s, black cats often appeared as integral roles in horror films. But around the time of World War II, black cats became firmly established Halloween symbols—but this time as good luck! Trick-or-treating had become a holiday tradition, and the presence of a black cat at your door protected your home from evil spirits that might come knocking.
Apparently, black cats are particularly seen as a symbol of good luck in the UK and Asia. For example, in Japan, there’s a belief that a black cat is good luck and if owned by a single woman, this will bring her many suitors. Here in the UK, apparently it’s a tradition in the Midlands that a black cat given as a wedding present is thought to bring good luck to the bride. And despite pirates being scared of cats as I said previously, today, fishermen in some cultures believe that it is actually good luck to have a black cat on board ship, and it is doubly lucky if they also have a black cat living in their home.
Unfortunately, a stigma against black cats remains to this day. Many superstitions about black cats still linger: some believe it is bad luck for a black cat to cross your path; you should never turn your back on a black cat or you will be cursed; a black cat on the bed of an ill person will bring death. Animal shelters still struggle to rehome black cats (and also apparently black dogs, too).
My message to you if you’re thinking of adopting a cat - black cats are the best and they will not haunt your home or bring a curse on your entire family, so please adopt them and love them!! And if you have cats of your own, please give them a big cuddle from me and apologise on behalf of humankind for giving them such a tragic history.
Scarecrows
Anyone who regularly watches horror movies (or has seen that episode of Doctor Who) knows just how creepy scarecrows can be. They often move in strange and creepy ways, and can even be demonic killers. However, on the complete opposite end of the spectrum, they can be fun and seasonally decorated, or silly and loveable like Worzel Gummidge (one of my childhood favourites) or the scarecrow in The Wizard of Oz. So let’s have a look at where scarecrows came from and how they came to be associated with magic and spooks.
In the fields of ancient Greece, wooden statues were placed in the fields, carved to represent Priapus, the Greek God who was the son of Aphrodite and Dionysus. I know we love a bit of Greek mythology on this podcast, so I had to expand on this and explain why, because I can’t just do a straightforward episode without falling down a million and one rabbit holes during my research.
It is said that Aphrodite yielded to the embraces of Dionysus and became pregnant, but during his expedition to India, she became faithless to him, and lived for a while with Adonis. On Dionysus' return from India, she went to meet him, but soon left him again, and went to give birth to their child. But Hera, wife of Zeus, as vengeful as she was, was dissatisfied with Aphrodite’s affair and cursed her to give birth to a child of extreme ugliness. This child was Priapus.
Because of his ugliness, he was refused entrance to Mount Olympus by the other gods and was tossed into a field where he was brought up by Shepherds. He fell in love with a nymph and pursued her endlessly, but she wanted nothing to do with him. This made him angry, causing him to be cursed with freakishly large and permanently erect male genitalia.
So, back to scarecrows. As far back as 3000 years ago, farmers have been making scarecrows in an attempt to scare birds out of their crop fields, with perhaps the first scarecrows being made by Egyptians. It is believed that around 2500 years ago, Greek farmers made their scarecrows in the form of Priapus for two main reasons: his ugliness would scare off the critters, and his massive genitalia would aid in the fertility of the crops.
Pre-feudal Japan also used different kinds of scarecrows in their rice fields, but the most popular one was the kakashi. Old dirty rags and noisemakers like bells and sticks were mounted on a pole in the field and then lit on fire. The flames (and presumably, the smell) kept birds and other animals away from the rice fields. The word kakashi meant "something stinky." Eventually, Japanese farmers began making scarecrows that looked like people in raincoats and hats. Sometimes they were equipped with weapons to make them look even more frightening.
During the Middle Ages in Britain and Europe, scarecrows would come in the form of small children. Their job was to run around in the fields, clapping blocks of wood together, to frighten away birds that might eat the grain. As the medieval period wound down and the plague wiped out much of the population, farmers discovered there was a shortage of spare children to run around shooing birds away. Instead, they stuffed old clothes with straw, placed a turnip or gourd up on top, and mounted the figure in the fields. They soon found that these lifelike guardians did a pretty good job of keeping crows away. This is closest to the kind of scarecrow we know today.
Scarecrows are also found in Native American cultures. Men would sit on raised platforms and shout at birds or ground animals that came near the crops. Some native tribes discovered that soaking corn seeds in a poisonous herb mixture deterred birds as well. In the Southwest, some Native American children had contests to see who could make the most frightening scarecrow, and the Zuni tribe used lines of cedar poles strung with cords and animal skins to keep the birds away.
Today, scarecrows aren’t used so much for their original purpose except in some more rural communities, but they are used a lot as Halloween and autumn decorations. In the US, scarecrow decorations will stay all the way through Thanksgiving, symbolising the fall harvest and the autumn feast. In the US and UK, yearly scarecrow festivals mark the beginning of the harvest season, and the main event is usually a competition to make the most creative scarecrows.
The reason why they became such a big part of Halloween symbolism was because of their job of scaring away intruders. Their purpose is literally to instill fear!
Ghosts
Next up is ghosts, and this is a Halloween symbol that hits the historical trifecta when it comes to having its roots firmly grounded in Roman, Celtic and Catholic traditions: Roman celebrations of the dead, Celtic festival of Samhain (Sah-win), and Catholic All Saints Day.
Stories and beliefs in spirits have been around for thousands of years. We return to the Celtic festival of Samhain (Sah-win) that I talked about earlier. The Celts believed this to be the period when the veil between living and dead was thinnest and thus a time of reverence for and contact with the dead. From Samhain festivals, we see a strong connection between what would eventually grow into Halloween and the ghostly spirit world.
Historically, during Samhain (Sah-win) celebrations, huge bonfires were lit and tended to guide and welcome friendly spirits and frighten off evil ones, and generous portions of newly harvested foods were set out to comfort and honour the returned.
In Brittany, France, where pagan Celtic traditions continued into the Middle Ages, stone lighthouses, called Lanterns of the Dead, gave protection against malicious ghosts on Halloween. A town crier wandered the town at sundown on Halloween, warning citizens that ghosts were coming.
Ghosts really began to materialise around Halloween in the 1800s as Americans enjoyed telling ghost stories. Today they play a huge part in Halloween-related media, with fictional films, books and TV shows as well as endless popular ghost hunting shows, documentaries and YouTube videos. (They’re also the easiest Halloween costume that requires almost no effort - just chuck an old sheet with eye holes on your head and you’re done.)
Bats
Next up is bats. While not vicious, evil, or terrifying, bats have become a well-known symbol of Halloween. Just like cats, since the Middle Ages, bats have been linked to witches. They’re often seen flying from witch’s caves, or being used as part of a witch’s brew. Bat wings, blood, and other factors are notorious for being part of witch spell recipes.
It’s likely that bats were present at the earliest celebrations of Halloween-like festivals. As part of Samhain (Sah-win), the Celts lit large bonfires as I already mentioned, which attracted insects. The insects, in turn, attracted bats, which soon became associated with the festival. This is another reason why bats were linked to witches, too - when women accused of witchcraft were burned, bats might have been attracted to the flames.
Medieval folklore expanded upon the spooky connotation of bats with a number of superstitions built around the idea that bats were the harbingers of death. For example, in your exploration into the history of Halloween last year (again, it’s episode 37 if you’re interested), you said that in Nova Scotian mythology, if a bat settles in a house, a man in the family will die; if it flies around, a woman in the family will perish.
Eventually, vampire legends made their way into Halloween folklore, further reinforcing the bat as a Halloween symbol. By the time Bram Stoker published Dracula in 1897, a cornerstone of vampire lore was that they could turn into bats.
The connection between bats and Halloween is also seasonal, due to the fact that late October is the best time to witness the fall swarming—when bats flood the skies while making preparations for hibernation.
The Colours Black and Orange
Finally, we have one that’s maybe a little more abstract than the physical symbols we’ve covered so far: the common Halloween colours of orange and black. These colours are so prevalent throughout the season that we may not even realise they’re symbols. But not only are orange and black symbolically powerful individually, but they also form a sort of yin and yang representing the connection between life and death, and a reminder that Halloween has always served a dual purpose as harvest festival and festival of the dead.
Orange is the lively and vibrant colour of the autumn harvest, found in ripened fruits, vegetables, grains, autumn leaves, and of course, pumpkins. It’s also the colour of the flames that chase away evil spirits and welcome the return of departed friends and family. The colour orange itself psychologically generates a sense of well-being and optimism.
Black, on the other hand, is the colour of darkness, when unseen things can roam the earth, including beasts, malicious humans, and spirits set free. Black has almost always been associated with death and mourning. As Samhain (Sah-win) came Christianized into All Hallows Eve and then Halloween in the Middle Ages, witches were demonised by the Church and they became associated with the colour black as well, with black cauldrons, cloaks, hats, and black animal familiars such as cats, bats, owls, and spiders.
When we put the two colours together, they’ve become so much of a Halloween symbol that it actually looks odd to wear orange and black together in any other season. Together they symbolise the juncture of life and death, and show that the spooky season is a combination of the darkness of death and the liveliness of the harvest.
—
So that’s all of the symbols I’ve got time to talk about today. There are so many more, but I’ve covered the ones that have the most interesting stories and the most to say about them.
I was also going to cover the origins of Halloween traditions in this episode too, such as trick or treating, wearing costumes, apple bobbing, and more - but I just completely ran out of time (probably because I spent so long talking about cats). So what I’m going to do is record a special bonus part 2 that we’ll post exclusively on Patreon!
Sign up to receive email updates
Enter your name and email address below and I'll send you periodic updates about the podcast.
Support us on
